Sponsored by
Place your ad banner here.
Contact info@goanvoice.ca

Printer Friendly Version

Newsletter. Issue 2009-05. February 28, 2009

 
 
Newsline Canada
Convention News
News Clips From India
News Clips From Goa
Goan Voice UK
People Places and Things
Events
Obituary
Commentary
Announcement
Health & Wellness
 
Classified Adverts
Subscribe to Goan Voice
Contact Us
Links & Reference Section
Newsletter Archives
       2002-2003
       2004
       2005 2005 2005
       2006
      2007
      2008
      2009

Commentary

The statements, opinions, or views in the articles may not necessarily reflect that of the Goan Voice Canada.

 
A Lenten penance that lasts
February 23, 2009
BY CHRIS MILLER
WESTERN CATHOLIC REPORTER

http://www.wcr.ab.ca/news/2009/0223/penance022309.shtml

Don't be bothered with 'fiddly things;' aim for reconciliation, conversion, say local Catholics

The 2 purposes of Lent

Message from Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops Lent has two major purposes:

It recalls or prepares for Baptism and it emphasizes a spirit of penance. Through 40 days of closer attention to God’s word and of more fervent prayer, believers are prepared to celebrate the paschal mystery.

Lenten penance should aim to bring about a lasting change in behaviour, says a retired pastoral associate.

"What are the things you're doing that are causing problems at home, disruptions at work?" asks Sister Ada Toner. "Those are the things you should be giving up," instead of giving up eating chocolate, a practice that will resume as soon as Lent is over. Toner, a 91-year-old long-time pastoral assistant in Fort Saskatchewan, said penance takes many forms, from apologizing to an injured party to healing divisions in our families.

Lent's purpose is not to diminish life but to enrich it, she said. Too much time is wasted correcting the "little fiddly things" like not saying our prayers or disobeying our parents, whereas its focus ought to be more on the positives God has done in one's life. Toner, a Sister of Charity of the Immaculate Conception, is one of several local Catholics who spoke with the WCR about their practices for Lent, which begins with Ash Wednesday, Feb. 25.

"In the old days, Lent was about giving up all of the bad things you did," she said. But Lent should be more about reconciliation with those we have hurt.

"God forgives us totally, and we have to forgive ourselves. Make peace with what you have done to others and what others have done to you."

Lent, of course, is also about avoiding the daily inevitable temptations.

Toner said that Jesus was tempted to 1) turn a rock into bread during his 40-day fast, 2) rule the world, and 3) throw himself from the temple roof to see if the angels would catch him.

"These temptations are ours too," she said.

Sister Gloria Keylor, provincial superior of Sisters of Providence, said her Lenten penance aims at a growth in holiness, a spiritual renewal.

"I'm trying to love kindness more and be less critical of others," said Keylor.

For Roni Iwanciwski, pastoral assistant at Our Lady of the Foothills Parish in Hinton, personal penance is to spend more time in prayer. But there are many activities in her parish too. The Catholic Women's League hands out Lenten crosses with its activities. And the parish has adult education classes in the evenings, four nights a week. The last two years those classes have focused on the Nicene Creed.

Catholic schools throughout Alberta are also active with Lent. Through the Positive Choice Leadership Program at Lloydminster's Holy Rosary High School, students find a deeper conversion of their hearts to the Lord. "We usually have our student leadership council in charge," said principal Tim Brochu. "This can take on multiple forms, such as service projects, local fundraisers or global awareness."

About 50 students with the school's worship and praise bands have been on the road recently. Brochu said the students have been putting on shows, starting Feb. 21 in Fort Saskatchewan, at 10 different schools. These shows include music and skits. Holy Rosary High School is closely connected with St. Anthony, the Border City's sole Catholic parish, he said. "It's a really unique situation, one parish in a small setting."

Oblate Father Mike Dechant said his BEARS Team will be active in junior high schools during Lent. BEARS stands for the five beliefs that junior high students need: belonging, excellence, accountability, respect and safety.

The school-based program is about "students animating students," Dechant said. During Lent, students lead Morning Prayer in the classrooms.
 
Lenten discipline allows us to get our priorities straight
By: Glen Argan
From:
http://www.wcr.ab.ca/columns/editorials/2009/editorial022309.shtml


Contemporary Western society is not the easiest place to grow closer to God. Our unparalleled wealth makes it easy to focus on fulfilling an endless array of material desires; a culture saturated in sex makes it easy to live a life addicted to sexual pleasures; an ideology of personal freedom legitimizes one’s ignoring of traditional morals.

It may be that other societies also had such a full table of temptations. But in the West today, a powerful mass media also places that table at centre stage.

The discipline of Lent offers a different focus. It is an opportunity to respond to St. Paul’s plea: “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your minds, so that you may discern what is the will of God — what is good and acceptable and perfect” (Romans 12.2).

In considering the Lenten disciplines of prayer, fasting and almsgiving, we need to overcome the notion that such disciplines are life-denying. Other religions can give the impression that the body and even the individuality of the person are evil. While there certainly have been ascetical excesses in Christianity, the goal of Christian penance is the fullness of life. Jesus’ words hold fast for all time: “I came that they may have life and have it abundantly” (John 10.10).

Moral theologian Germain Grisez notes that the Lenten disciplines contribute to our ongoing conversion in that “sin alienates the sinner from God, upsets the order of the self and damages human community; but prayer draws one nearer to God, fasting imposes order on oneself, almsgiving expresses love of neighbour which forms community.”

The decline in ascetical practices in recent decades has not been a form of liberation. Rather, it shows a lack of awareness of how sin diminishes us and how the fullness of life comes through the love of God and love of neighbour.

In his letter Reconciliation and Penance, Pope John Paul II noted that “the moral conscience of many people (has) become seriously clouded” in our time. “The restoration of a proper sense of sin is the first way of facing the grave spiritual crisis looming over man today” (n. 18).

This declining awareness of sin is, in turn, due to a declining awareness of God. We have too often privatized God and made him subject to my plans and desires. We do not let God be God, the one who is outside and above us, the one who has great love for us, but also the one who calls each of us to fullness of life. Our call is to respond to his love, not to expect he will be obedient to our whims.

Lent is an opportunity to get our priorities straight. It is a time to take another step in that lifelong task of conversion. Its rich resources in the call to prayer, fasting and almsgiving are an opportunity to enter into the fullness of life.
 
Fight Poverty to Foster Peace
Editorial from: http://examinerindia.blogspot.com/2009/02/editorial.html

Adapted extracts from Pope’s Message for World Peace Day 2009


Pope Benedict XVI has called on nations of the world and individuals to play an active part in fighting poverty as a means of building world peace, in his message for the Word Day of Peace. The Message stresses that poverty is often a contributory factor or a compounding element in conflicts, including armed ones. “Our world” he said, “shows increasing evidence of another grave threat to peace: many individuals, and indeed, whole peoples are living today in conditions of extreme poverty.”

Poverty is often considered as a consequence of demographic change and hence there are international campaigns to reduce birth rates. Many methods fail to respect the right to life, exterminating unborn children in the name of the fight against poverty, constituting destruction of the poorest of all human beings. But recent studies show that those with higher birth rates enjoy better opportunities for development. The Pope’s message points out that population is proving to be an asset, not a factor that contributes to poverty.

An important area that requires attention in the fight against poverty, is child poverty. “When poverty strikes a family”, the Pontiff says, “the children prove to be the most vulnerable victims: almost half of those living in absolute poverty today are children. Working for the welfare of children means giving priority to those objectives which concern them most directly, such as caring for mothers, commitment to education, access to vaccines, medical care and drinking water, safeguarding the environment and above all, commitment to defence of the family and the stability of relations within it.”

Another aspect of poverty is the current food crisis. “This problem”, the Pope says, “is characterised by difficulty in gaining access to it, and by a structural lack of political and economic institutions capable of addressing needs and emergencies.” Pope Benedict said food shortages and high food prices were “not created by a lack of food, as much as by the phenomenon of speculation and the inability of economic and political institutions to deal with needs and emergencies.”

The Holy Father attributed the current global financial crisis to the fact that: “financial activity is only focussed on itself without any long-term consideration of the common good’’. He called for a “common code of ethics” to counter the trend in a globalised world in which the gap between rich and poor was widening, instead of being narrowed.

The “conscience of humanity” could no longer ignore economic differences that had become more marked, even in the more advanced countries. He also urged governments to spend less on armaments and more on development, saying that “immense military expenditure is diverted from development projects for the poor’’.

Pope Benedict argued that every form of externally imposed poverty has at its root a lack of respect for the transcendent dignity of the human person, adding: “when man is not considered within the total context of his vocation, and when the demands of a true human ecology are not respected, the cruel forces of poverty are unleashed.”

Pope Benedict highlighted that development needs to be oriented towards a goal of profound solidarity that seeks the good of each and all. “In this sense”, he affirmed, “globalisation should be seen as a good opportunity to achieve something important in the fight against poverty, and to place at the disposal of justice and peace resources which were scarcely conceivable previously.” Our axiom should be ‘fight poverty to foster peace’.
 
They aren't Dogs, in those Slums
(Juan Cole, Global Americana Institute)

http://www.juancole.com/2009/02/they-arent-dogs-in-those-slums.html
From: goanet-news-bounces@lists.goanet.org 
February 24, 2009 To:
gn-news@goanet.org
By Julian Cole

The following comments may contain spoilers.

Directors Danny Boyle's and Loveleen Tandan's "Slumdog Millionaire" swept the Oscars this year, in a remarkable sign of globalization. The creative team behind the film was largely British (Tandan began as a casting director and the screenplay was by Simon Beaufoy). But it was based on an Indian novel (Vikas Swarup's Q & A), set in India with Indian actors, and deployed the cinematic techniques of Bollywood, the massive Indian film industry based in Bombay (a city that Indian television news anchors now call Mumbai but almost no one else does).

Globalization is implicit in the story from every direction. Author Swarup is an Indian diplomat as well as novelist, and has had postings in Turkey, the US, Britain and Ethiopia, and he is now Indian High Commissioner in Pretoria, South Africa. So the story springs from the mind of an inveterate expatriate who knows Ankara and Washington as well as Delhi.

And, the audience reception of the film was global, with Indian slum dwellers mounting angry protests, especially against the title. ("Dog," or kutta is a highly derogatory thing to call someone in Hindi, maybe as pejorative as "pig" in the US. Most Indians don't keep dogs as pets, and they are therefore often street animals and go feral. I tried to keep some dogs around as watchdogs in Lucknow by feeding them, but it was always a crap shoot whether they would attack me or the burglars). Just imagine if a film came out in the US about inner city minorities called "Ghetto Pigs." Anti-globalization writer and acclaimed novelist Arundhati Roy slammed the film for neglecting to depict the real working class and its struggles, instead holding out the false hope of sudden riches.

If poverty-stricken urbanites were upset by the title, the concentration on Indian poverty disturbed middle and upper class Indians who have seen their country advance from fourth-world poverty to the elements of an advanced economy. (Within India's more than one billion population, there is a middle-class country of 80 million, the size of Germany--with satellite televisions, nice cars, well-appointed homes, and white collar jobs hooked into the world economy). I can't tell you how tired middle class South Asians get of the Western depiction of their region as destitute, or the use of it to make Western children clean their plates.

That the film was feted in Hollywood even as it was reviled in parts of India was anyway a huge change. As recently as 1992, legendary Bengali director Satyajit Ray received a lifetime achievement Oscar as a nod to the cognoscenti. Ray and other Indian auteurs were in some sense in another universe, off-stage, and so could be symbolically honored at the Oscars. "Slumdog" was the life of this year's party. India has arrived in American arts.

Boyle, the director of "Trainspotting," brings his dark vision to this depiction of Indian slum life. Both films contain disgusting immersions in toilets in fulfillment of an obsession, whether with a cocaine high or the autograph of Indian acting giant Amitabh Bachchan. Both contain scenes of gratuitous violence, whether the smashing of a patron's face by a beer bottle carelessly and indiscriminately thrown from an upper story in a pub, or the cocky gunplay of a budding Bombay gangster. (It is one of the flaws in the argument of figures such as actor Amitabh Bachchan that the film is unfair to India, that Boyle did not exactly portray a Western place like Scotland in a complimentary way, either; he is interested in the downtrodden and hopeless, wherever they are.)

"Slumdog Millionaire" also draws heavily on Bollywood tropes. While most such films are 3-hour melodramas about star-crossed lovers who have to outwit their hidebound parents to get married, "Slumdog" substitutes a gangster brother and his gangster fictive family for the meddling groom's parents as a plot device for keeping the lovers apart. While greed or perhaps a drive to escape existential boredom drove "Trainspotting," Jamal Malik's (Dev Patel's) unceasing search for his beloved Latika (Freida Pinto) drives "Slumdog."

But Bollywood themes are also sidestepped. Whereas in most Indian films, a love affair between a Muslim boy like Jamal and a Hindu girl like Latika would be impeded by caste conventions that make such unions socially difficult, in this film that they are orphans and slum dwellers deracinates them to the point where caste and religion are irrelevant. The only one who practices religion in this film is Jamal's gangster older brother Salim, and even this dallying with mainstream belief and practice has the distinct disadvantage for him of endowing him with a belated conscience. The other context in which religion appears is the Shiv Sena Hindu mob that attacks Jamal's family and neighborhood, imprinting on his mind the appearance of the God Ram (which otherwise a poor Muslim boy might know little about).

The film is plot-driven, not character-driven. In fact, it is puzzle-driven, since each episode in Jamal's life, in almost picaresque fashion, is told around the answer to a question on the Indian version of "Who wants to be a Millionaire?" (The other side of globalization is that such television phenomena typically have iterations in each major country around the world; Indian Idol is now very popular).

Jamal's character, with his quiet stubborn integrity, never alters from childhood to adulthood. Salim is a fighter throughout. And Latika is never defined, swinging between easy coquetry, realistic debauchery, resigned domestic slavery and the high-mindedness of having a one true love. It is the failure of character development and the concentration on puzzle-solving that are the least satisfying and least realistic elements of the film. Would Jamal really never have learned to compromise, ethically or otherwise, in the conditions under which he grew up? Would not Latika have been warped and neurotic and disease-ridden after those years of sexual bondage?

The glamorization of the poor in the film was among the elements that provoked howls of outrage in India itself, drawing charges of "poverty porn" and the promotion of ghetto tourism on the part of the Western affluent.

That the film depicts an one-dimensional view of the poorer areas of Bombay is undeniable. There are Fagins and pimps, gangsters and corrupt building contractors, courtesans and orphans. But poor neighborhoods in India are a dense thicket of social and economic networks, with a working class, shopkeepers, peddlers, and other responsible if poor citizens toiling to eke out an honest living. The film eschews the urban working class for an unrealistic focus solely on the criminal element. Extortion rackets exist. But they prey on small restaurants and shops. If there were no honest workers or businesses, there would be no way to extract protection money.

Both the celebrations and the protests, the bouquets and the brickbats attest the increasing connectedness of the human world, in what Teilhard de Chardin called the "noosphere." Only in a cyberspace-enabled noosphere could worker activists in the poor areas of Bombay mount real-time protests even as a plethora of golden Oscars were handed out in the poshest venue on the planet. And if the workers in Bombay can as a result of the success of the film draw the attention of the world to the costs of unregulated "flat" globalization, if they can counter Friedmanism from the heart of the displacements caused by Neoliberalism, then the saga of Jamal Malik will have had an impact far beyond the realm of cinema. They aren't dogs. They are productive human beings. And their struggle is not over.

Goan Voice designed and compiled by Demerg Systems Indiaa,
ALFRAN PLAZA, "C" Block, 2nd Floor, S-43/44,
(Near Don Bosco School), Panjim, Goa-403001
Tel: +91 0832 2420797 Email: info@goanvoice.ca